Statement by the Executive Board of the ENCJ on Poland - 17 July 2017 PDF Print E-mail
The Executive Board of the ENCJ is greatly dismayed to learn that both the lower and the upper house of the Polish Parliament last week approved two reforms which have been the subject of trenchant criticism over the past year. Furthermore, also last week a draft law was introduced in Parliament  that affects the composition of the Supreme Court.
The first law which has been approved is the reform of the Polish Judges’ Council. This reform was analysed by the Executive Board of the ENCJ on 30 January 2017, when it was pointed out that there had been no meaningful consultation with the Polish Judges’ Council; that this reform involves termination of the mandate of the Polish Judges’ Council’s members; that the appointment of the judicial members of the Judges’ Council by Parliament is not in line with the ENCJ’s standards and that the establishment of two assemblies within the Polish Judges’ Council (the first one formed by the 15 judges appointed by Parliament and the second one including six members from the Polish Parliament, the Minister of Justice, a representative of the Head of State, the President of the Supreme Court and the President of the High Administrative Court) , allied with a requirement that any resolution by the Judges’ Council has to be adopted by both assemblies sitting separately, gives a substantial role to politicians in the selection and appointment of judges.
The second law approved by Parliament gives the Minister of Justice the power to dismiss court presidents and substitute them within the next six months after the entering into force of this new law.
These laws will inevitably involve an erosion in judicial independence with an equally inevitable impact on the Rule of Law.
So, too, the draft law introduced on  12th July which involves the dissolution of the current Supreme Court by imposing retirement on its members and giving the Minister of Justice the discretionary power to designate those judges who shall remain in active service
The ENCJ’s Executive Board considers that this is a very grave situation.
Indeed, at the ENCJ’s recent General Assembly in June 2017, the Paris Declaration included this statement:
“The developments and planned judicial reform in Poland continue to raise serious concern as they could seriously endanger the separation of powers which is vital to the maintenance of the Rule of Law. The ENCJ reiterates that a key requirement for maintaining and enhancing mutual trust between judicial authorities in the EU, as a basis for mutual recognition, is the independence, quality and efficiency of each of the judicial systems and respect in every state for the Rule of Law.“
So serious are the concerns about the developments in Poland that Councils for the Judiciaries across Europe have echoed these sentiments over the past few months. Specifically, statements have been made by:
Conseil Superieur de la Justice Belgium
Raad voor de rechtspraak, Netherlands
Supreme Judicial Council, Bulgaria
Conselho Superior da Magistratura, Portugal
Državno Sudbeno Vijeće, Croatia
Consiliul Superior al Magistraturii, Romania
Association of Council of State Judges, Greece Sudna Rada, Slovakia
Association of Judges of Ireland
Sodni Svet, Slovenia
Consiglio Superiore della Magistratura, Italy
Consejo General del Poder Judicial , Spain
Tieslietu Padome, Latvia
Judges' Council of England and Wales
Teiseju taryba, Lithuania
Judges' Council of Scotland
It is imperative that judicial independence is respected by governments. A democratic system based on the Rule of Law can only properly function if judges’ independence is safeguarded. Furthermore, as made clear in the Paris Declaration and in an earlier statement issued by the ENCJ’s Executive Board on 26 April 2017, judicial independence is critically important in maintaining and enhancing mutual trust between judicial authorities in the EU. Judicial independence also plays a central and indispensable role in ensuring respect for EU law.
Brussels, 17 July 2017

The first law which has been approved is the reform of the Polish Judges’ Council. This reform was analysed by the Executive Board of the ENCJ on 30 January 2017, when it was pointed out that there had been no meaningful consultation with the Polish Judges’ Council; that this reform involves termination of the mandate of the Polish Judges’ Council’s members; that the appointment of the judicial members of the Judges’ Council by Parliament is not in line with the ENCJ’s standards and that the establishment of two assemblies within the Polish Judges’ Council (the first one formed by the 15 judges appointed by Parliament and the second one including six members from the Polish Parliament, the Minister of Justice, a representative of the Head of State, the President of the Supreme Court and the President of the High Administrative Court), allied with a requirement that any resolution by the Judges’ Council has to be adopted by both assemblies sitting separately, gives a substantial role to politicians in the selection and appointment of judges.

The second law approved by Parliament gives the Minister of Justice the power to dismiss court presidents and substitute them within the next six months after the entering into force of this new law.

These laws will inevitably involve an erosion in judicial independence with an equally inevitable impact on the Rule of Law. So, too, the draft law introduced on  12th July which involves the dissolution of the current Supreme Court by imposing retirement on its members and giving the Minister of Justice the discretionary power to designate those judges who shall remain in active service.

The ENCJ’s Executive Board considers that this is a very grave situation.  

Indeed, at the ENCJ’s recent General Assembly in June 2017, the Paris Declaration included this statement:

“The developments and planned judicial reform in Poland continue to raise serious concern as they could seriously endanger the separation of powers which is vital to the maintenance of the Rule of Law. The ENCJ reiterates that a key requirement for maintaining and enhancing mutual trust between judicial authorities in the EU, as a basis for mutual recognition, is the independence, quality and efficiency of each of the judicial systems and respect in every state for the Rule of Law.“ 

So serious are the concerns about the developments in Poland that Councils for the Judiciaries across Europe have echoed these sentiments over the past few months. Specifically, statements have been made by: 

Conseil Superieur de la Justice Belgium

Supreme Judicial Council, Bulgaria

Državno Sudbeno Vijeće, Croatia

Association of Council of State Judges, Greece

Association of Judges of Ireland

Consiglio Superiore della Magistratura, Italy

Tieslietu Padome, Latvia

Teiseju taryba, Lithuania

Raad voor de rechtspraak, Netherlands

Conselho Superior da Magistratura, Portugal

Consiliul Superior al Magistraturii, Romania

Sudna Rada, Slovakia

Sodni Svet, Slovenia

Consejo General del Poder Judicial , Spain

Judges' Council of England and Wales

Judges’Council of Northern Ireland

Judicial Council of Scotland

It is imperative that judicial independence is respected by governments. A democratic system based on the Rule of Law can only properly function if judges’ independence is safeguarded. Furthermore, as made clear in the Paris Declaration and in an earlier statement issued by the ENCJ’s Executive Board on 26 April 2017, judicial independence is critically important in maintaining and enhancing mutual trust between judicial authorities in the EU. Judicial independence also plays a central and indispensable role in ensuring respect for EU law.

pdf version of the statement

On 20 July 2017 the ENCJ President was interviewd by a Polish television channel (TVN). 

Reactions by other organisations

Statement by the CCJE Bureau

Letter CCBE President

Letter SG CoE Jagland

Statement by MEDEL

Statement President Venice Commission

Reaction European Commission 19 July

Letter EAJ to President Duda

 
ENCJ President speaks in the European Parliament PDF Print E-mail

On 22 June 2017 the President of the ENCJ was invited to address the LIBE meeting with the national parliaments of the Member States on the EU Mechanism on Democracy, Rule of Law and Fundamental Rights. In her speech she reflected on the role of the national parliaments in safeguarding the independence of the judiciary. To watch the addres click here (from 1:56 Nuria Díaz Abad is gving her address). 

nda_libe_june_2017

 
ENCJ adopts Paris Declaration on resilient justice PDF Print E-mail

The ENCJ gathered from 7th to 9th June in the Cour de Cassation in Paris for its General Assembly. The central theme of resilient justice was discussed and the Paris declaration was adopted. In it the ENCJ calls upon the European Institutions and Member States to guarantee judicial independence in accordance with the Rule of Law, and, furthermore, calls upon Councils for the Judiciary and Judges at all times to be resilient in the face of the challenges which face them.

The ENCJ report on Independence, Accountability and Quality of the Judiciary was also adopted and contains the outcomes of the 2016/2017 survey among judges on their independence.

 
General Assembly elects new Board members PDF Print E-mail

On the 7th of June 2017 the ENCJ Members gathered in Paris to elect  3 new Board members. 

The Državnosudbeno vijeće / State Judicial Council of Croatia, the Portuguese Conselho Superior da Magistratura and the Judges' Council of England and Wales were elected into the Board for two years.

The French, Irish and Italian Councils for the Judiciary ended their mandate as Board member.

 
ENCJ President addresses the congress of Polish Lawyers in Katowice PDF Print E-mail
On 20 May 2017 over a 1000 lawyers and judges gathered in Katowice in Poland for a congress to discuss the reform of the judiciary and the state of the rule of law in Poland. The congress was organised by the Association of Polish Judges "Iustitia", the Supreme Bar Council and the National Council of Legal Advisers. The President of the ENCJ Ms Nuria Diaz Abad addressed the audience and explained ENCJ's position in relation to the planned judicial reform in Poland. 
 
  • «
  •  Start 
  •  Prev 
  •  1 
  •  2 
  •  3 
  •  4 
  •  5 
  •  6 
  •  7 
  •  8 
  •  9 
  •  10 
  •  Next 
  •  End 
  • »


Page 1 of 19
ENCJ News
05/04/2016 > CCJE and the CCPE publish report on the challenges for judicial impartiality and independence in Council of Europe member States
article thumbnail

Report from the CCJE and the CCPE on the main challenges for judicial impartiality and independence in Council of Europe member States The Bureaus of the Consultative Council of European Judges (CCJE [ ... ]


New on the website

Statement by the Executive Board of the ENCJ on Poland - 17 July 2017

The Executive Board of the ENCJ is greatly dismayed to learn that both the lower and the upper house of the Polish Parliament last week approved two reforms which have been the subject of trenchant criticism over the past year. Furthermore,...

ENCJ President speaks in the European Parliament

On 22 June 2017 the President of the ENCJ was invited to address the LIBE meeting with the national parliaments of the Member States on the EU Mechanism on Democracy, Rule of Law and Fundamental Rights. In her speech she reflected on the role...

ENCJ report Alternative Dispute Resolution and the Judicial Domain

In 2016-2017 the ENCJ studies the issue of Alternative Dispute Resolution and the Judicial Domain. The idea for the Project resulted from the fact that there are a number of ongoing changes to the ways in which civil, family and even some...

ENCJ adopts Paris Declaration on resilient justice

The ENCJ gathered from 7th to 9th June in the Cour de Cassation in Paris for its General Assembly. The central theme of resilient justice was discussed and the Paris declaration was adopted. In it the ENCJ calls upon the European Institutions...

General Assembly elects new Board members

On the 7th of June 2017 the ENCJ Members gathered in Paris to elect  3 new Board members.  The Državnosudbeno vijeće / State Judicial Council of Croatia, the Portuguese Conselho Superior da Magistratura and the Judges' Council of...

ENCJ President addresses the congress of Polish Lawyers in Katowice

On 20 May 2017 over a 1000 lawyers and judges gathered in Katowice in Poland for a congress to discuss the reform of the judiciary and the state of the rule of law in Poland. The congress was organised by the Association of Polish Judges...

Statement of the ENCJ Executive Board concerning judicial reforms in Poland

The ENCJ has been following the situation in Poland closely and has on several occasions called upon the executive to respect the independence of the judiciary, and to undertake reforms to the justice system only after meaningful consultation...

2017 EU Justice Scoreboard

The European Commissioner for Justice and Consumers Ms. Vera Jourova presented the 2017 EU Justice Scoreboard on Monday 10th April. According to the Commission this 5th edition of the EU Justice Scoreboard confirms that effective justice...
Relevant EU News
EC DG Justice

 

 

| Contact by post mail // phone | Link section | Website creation and hosting by Pragmawork | All right reserved 2010 |